In oneĬontrolled experiment coordinated by a group of GE(nie®) scientistsĪnd skeptics, MERLIN assigned accident dates to their respective Overall, MERLIN's accuracy has approached 80 percent. In particular, there is this mention of their experimental results: Project sees itself - and intends to be seen - as a serious However, the results that did come up clearly indicate that the Merlin ://and only a few of these were in a context that might be regarded as scientific. I searched the Merlin site for any of the following terms: "science"? Are they claiming to have achieved some sort of scientific Now, how does the Merlin Project fare in regard to the two items above?įirst - and in fairness to the Merlin Project - we should ask a veryįundamental question: Are they even presenting themselves as Science is certainly an important consideration. Pseudoscience, the immersion (or lack thereof) in the culture of So on, all presented in curriculm vitae with long lists of educationalĪlthough not as essential to distinguishing science from University, lists of publications, positions in learned societies, and Have a set of scientific "credentials" - degrees from such-and-such a Scientific meetings and present their findings before other scientistsįor critical review and evalution. Referenced with papers from other scientific journals. Their work in peer-reviewed scientific journals. "controlled" experiments, and then making detailed informationĪccessible about one's experiments and results.Īnother way of recognizing science is that scientists are generallyįairly-well steeped in the culture of their profession. Wikipedia also emphasizes reproducibility - other scientists shouldīe able to duplicate the results of a scientific experiment, to assist Predictions about yet-to-be observed phenomenon Proposal of explanations about the mechanisms underlying those Careful observation of events in the world around us This is a nice overview that captures many key features: The scientific method isĮssentially an extremely cautious means of building a supportable,Įvidenced understanding of our world. Which is cogent enough to make predictions can then be tested Prediction turns out to be correct, the theory survives. Predictions from these theories are tested by experiment. In the form of theories: observations, hypotheses, and deductions. Scientists propose new assertions about our world Scientific investigation and acquisition of new knowledge based upon The scientific method or process is considered fundamental to the School-book lessons on the scientific method: We can turn to the ever-useful Wikipedia for a reminder of our Pseudoscience, it helps to lay out some of the markers that can used In asking whether the work of the Merlin Project is science or Re: Need someone to evaluate "Merlin Project" I'd really like to know and I?d reallyĪppreciate hearing a considered opinion on this, and thanks for your Program is physicist Dr, George Hart, who is credited with inventing The incredible thing is the author of the Up" after the fact-who knows? But is has an aura of scientificĬredibility about it. Now it is very possible this could have all been "cooked Paper" to the Joint Chiefs of Staffs in 1996 about terrorism and postĪ pdf doc. They also claim to have written a consultory "white Several years at the beginning of this century they claim predicted The authors claim their formula pointed out ("predicted") Project was taken seriously enough to be covered by several news The authors have developed a computer program combined withĪstronomical positions to come up with predictions. Questions as to why I'm researching this and the validity, or lack I've no answer from them yet, but it serves to point out 12:18 PST I am enclosing a portion of a letter I've written to CSICOP on this It or is it just bunk.Please make your answers as simple as possible. There are some extraordinary claims made by the men whoĭeveloped this ?system? and I?d like to know if there is anything to Math major or a scientist, but I?m sure that there is someone whoĬould evaluate it to see if it?s pseudoscience, which is what I would With attention to the methodology/theory it poses Would like someone with math/analytical/critical thinking skills to Need someone to evaluate "Merlin Project"
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |